The Voice of Lee Schwartz, father of two former NFL studs, Geoffrey and Mitchell Schwartz, author of Raising Giants and member of Concussion & CTE Foundation’s West Coast Advisory Board . . .

THE NFL CAN BREAK YOU

One was a recent first ballot Hall of Famer.  The other a certain first ballot selection.  Both played in the trenches as offensive tackles.  And both have something much more critical in common.

The physical toll that football exacts on its players is common knowledge.  The emotional impact is hardly ever discussed.  But then one day it all comes into focus, as it has recently with Joe Thomas and Lane Johnson.

Thomas, Mitchell’s teammate for his four years on the Cleveland roster, suited up for 11 years as a Brown.  Ten of those years he earned Pro Bowl selections, six first-team honors.  Individually he rose above those around him.  But now let’s look at Cleveland’s fortunes as a team during Thomas tenure.

  • Overall team record of 48 wins, 128 losses!
  • One, that’s right, one winning season in his rookie year. The translates to 10 consecutive years playing for a team that couldn’t reach a .500 threshold.
  • Playoff appearances? ZERO!

As one NFL analyst asserted, “The Browns literally mentally broke Joe Thomas, one of the greatest players the game has ever seen.”  According to Thomas, “the emotional toll of spending nearly a decade trying to convince myself that the Browns were Super Bowl contenders” finally caused him to hit a breaking point.  The Browns ineptitude simply crushed Thomas’ individual brilliance.

To his credit, Thomas sought help from a team psychologist.  Instead of continuing to internalize his struggles feeling as though he had reached a personal tipping point, he was able to confront a reality that had eluded him for most of his career.  Thomas could no longer fool himself into thinking that the Browns were to be Super Bowl contenders.

Imagine for a moment having to perform at the highest levels burdened by this emotional baggage.  Maybe adding to the mental turmoil was his carrying the mantle of being the NFL’s Iron Man.  That recognition was earned by being on the field for 10,363 consecutive snaps.  The streak came to an end when he tore his left triceps tendon.  (BTW, Mitchell assumed that distinguished honor until his streak ended after 7,894 consecutive snaps.)  That was also the end of Thomas’ career.  I suspect that at some level he didn’t walk away earlier in deference to this incredible accomplishment.

Lane Johnson rewrote the perception of right tackles.  Before him, only left tackles were held in high regard . . . and I can speak to that from a personal perspective.  The perception of Mitchell’s accomplishments during his career . . . especially during his time with the Kansas City Chiefs . . . was dampened by his being a right tackle.  Not once as a Chief was he selected to the NFL’s Pro Bowl team.  That was strictly reserved for left tackles.  Yet he was named three times to the Associated Press’ All-Pro first team along with one second team nod.

Entering this season Johnson had hinted that this season might be his last.  He missed several training camp practices for personal reasons.  He apparently has had a long, public history of managing anxiety and depression.

Wanting to complete one final season, he forged ahead.  But four weeks into his 14th season, all with the Philadelphia Eagles, Johnson called it quits.  He stated that his priorities had shifted, prioritizing his mental health and family over the game of football.

Johnson was no longer 100% mentally committed to his craft.  I’ve heard Geoffrey and Mitchell both say that the game of football is taxing enough when one’s fully committed.  When a player is no longer all in, then they must be all out, for their own good as well as for their teammates.

Imagine the strength it took for Johnson to walk away from a game that had given him so much and for which he gave every ounce of his being.  But as difficult as the decision may have been, in the end he had his priorities in the right place.  Too bad some who follow sports professionally don’t possess the same courage.

In a prior blog, I wrote about Stephan A. Smith’s initial reaction to Johnson’s announcement.  Insensitively, Smith initially questioned Johnson’s retirement, implying that Johnson used mental health as an excuse to retire because of the Eagles’ early season struggles.  This might be the exact reason why athletes don’t talk about mental health struggles, fearful of the undeserving ridicule they may receive.

Both Thomas and Johnson were goliaths on the field.  Thank goodness they are titans off the gridiron.  By sharing their stories about mental health challenges, they give others permission to be so transparent.  Hopefully though, others may turn toward professional help long before the stresses and strains impact their daily being.

But regardless of when a player might admit to challenges, there’s a hard truth to these stories.  Yes, the NFL provides opportunities most will never achieve.  Fame.  Fortune.  Legacy.  Glory.  Prestige.  But there can be a price to pay.