The Voice of Lee Schwartz, father of two former NFL studs, Geoffrey and Mitchell Schwartz, author of Raising Giants and member of Concussion & CTE Foundation’s West Coast Advisory Board . . .

PLAYING LIGHTWEIGHTS – REALLY?
The idea for this blog hatched after week three of the college football season. Now that the collegiate basketball season has tipped off, it’s only added fuel to the fire.
Looking ahead to the NCAA football schedule for Saturday, Oct. 3rd I stumbled upon a web page that displayed upcoming games for some top ranked teams. It was a head scratcher. Alabama vs. Chattanooga. Ole Miss vs. Wofford. LSU vs. McNeese. Miss. St. vs. Tennessee Tech. For real?
The first teams listed are members of the Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS), the top tier of college football. The second schools listed fall into the lower tier of the Football Championship Subdivision (FCS). Talent levels are like night and day. Varsity versus junior varsity at best.
Seeing this prompted me to dig deeper. I searched for college games during the first three weeks of the season that pitted a FBS member team against a school from the FCS. I found 10 such games. Of course all were won by the FBS team, resoundingly. The average winning margin was . . . hold your hat . . . 44 points. The point spread ranged from 16 to Oregon’s shutout of Portland State by a whopping 84 points.
Let’s move on to college basketball. In the last couple of days, the University of Southern California hoops team set a program record for margin of victory by demolishing Arkansas Pine-Bluff by 76 points. Your eyes aren’t deceiving you.
UCLA five days earlier “only” destroyed the same AR-Pine Bluff team by 69. And five days before that, the Bruins ran rough shot over North Florida by a “paltry” 49. Collegiate basketball doesn’t have the FBS and FCS designations but when looking at power ratings, both these schools are positioned deep in the lower tier of Division 1 basketball.
So I gotta ask . . . why? Why would top tier teams, blue bloods of their respective sports, schedule such lightweights? There are reasons for and against . . .
- Against: Not a competitive environment. Players will not improve by facing those with limited talent.
- For: Nice, before a season begins, to have game(s) already in the bank, so to speak.
- Against: I would suggest that bad habits could seep in because players don’t need to be at the top of their game.
- Against: Any player hurt, especially if leading to future games missed, during these contests would be shameful.
- For: The full squad is likely to find time on the field/court, especially important for the those who reside on the lower end of the roster and who would, under normal circumstances, not see the light of day otherwise.
- Against: Imagine for a moment the morale of the losing team. I once played competitive basketball. If my team got walloped in such a way, my emotions would be shattered. Plus, it’s simply no fun to lose by such margins.
- For & Against: Would fans of teams destined to be wiped out want to view such a contest? Certainly wouldn’t be high on most fans’ bucket lists except for maybe the most diehard supporters. And for the fans of the team performing the whitewash, based on personal experience, enthusiasm begins to wane long before the final whistle.
All this said, I believe that two reasons stand above the rest to explain why these games are scheduled.
One is financial. At least when it comes to football, the schools named above whose teams will suffer the indignity of getting roughed up will receive anywhere from $500,000 to $750,000 to show up. That’s not an inconsequential amount of money for these colleges.
The second reason, particularly in football where one game is a full 10th of an entire regular season, is spurred by concern about rankings and the ability to qualify for playoff football. If teams schedule a more competent opponent and end up losing that game, that one loss could prevent a postseason playoff appearance. I believe this is the overriding reason.
Bottom line, at least for me, is that I find no enjoyment as a fan watching these contests.

To blame it on someone else shows management potential.